My Quest to Find the Perfect Pair of Boxer Shorts at Old Navy

A First-Hand Account of Shopping for Men’s Underwear

As a guy who has worn boxer shorts for as long as I can remember, I consider myself somewhat of an expert when it comes to men’s underwear. I’ve tried all kinds of brands and styles over the years, but I keep coming back to Old Navy for high quality, comfortable boxer shorts at affordable prices.

Recently, I decided it was time to restock my underwear drawer. I headed to my local Old Navy store on a mission to find the perfect pair of boxer shorts. Keep reading to find out about my experience!

Evaluating the Styles of Old Navy Boxer Shorts

The first thing I noticed when browsing the men’s underwear section was the wide variety of styles offered by Old Navy. They have classic full-seat boxer shorts, as well as modern low-rise trunks and boxer briefs. I appreciate the range of options to suit different preferences.

Personally, I prefer a full-seat boxer for maximum comfort and coverage. Old Navy has some great basic cotton versions, as well as printed designs and colorful solids. The full-seat cut provides plenty of room to move around.

For guys who like a little less fabric, Old Navy has mid-rise and low-rise trunk boxer styles. The shorter leg openings are great for athletic builds. I may pick up a few pairs for working out or wearing under slimmer pants.

While I’m sticking with traditional boxers this time, my younger brother loves Old Navy’s boxer briefs. This style combines the coverage of a boxer with the fit of a brief. Old Navy’s quick-dry boxer briefs with mesh panels seem perfect for hikes and camping trips.

Finding the Right Size

Fit is arguably the most important factor when buying underwear. Luckily, Old Navy makes it easy to find your perfect size. Their boxer shorts come in traditional men’s sizes from small up to XXL.

I usually wear a size medium in most brands, and Old Navy is no exception. But it’s always smart to try on a few different sizes, as some cuts may fit smaller or looser.

Old Navy provides a sizing chart with exact measurements for the waist and inseam on each style. I recommend measuring your favorite existing pair of boxers and comparing to the size chart. This helps ensure the best match.

For maximum comfort, I prefer my boxer shorts to sit slightly below my waist without being too baggy in the legs. Trying on a few sizes in the fitting room helped me dial in the ideal fit. Don’t be afraid to size up or down as needed to get the right proportions.

Evaluating Boxer Short Materials

When trying on different styles, I paid attention to the material and construction. Old Navy uses a range of fabrics to suit different needs.

The majority of their classic full-seat boxers are made from ultra-soft 100% cotton. This natural fiber feels great against the skin and allows ventilation. The cotton boxer shorts come in both light and mid-weight fabrics.

For athletic guys, Old Navy has performance boxer briefs in high-tech synthetic materials. These wick moisture and have four-way stretch for movement. The mesh provides breathability during workouts.

They also offer some boxers in modal or cotton blends for added softness. I may try these for a more luxurious feel. The smooth fabrics help prevent chafing or irritation.

Overall, I’m impressed by the quality and comfort from all the materials. The Old Navy boxers seem durable enough for regular use and laundry.

Finding Great Prices on Boxer Shorts

As an avid bargain hunter, I always keep an eye out for sales and deals. Luckily, Old Navy boxer shorts are very reasonably priced even at full price. And they often have promotions that make them an even better value.

The basic cotton boxers generally cost between $10-15 per pair. That’s on par with other major brands. I stocked up on solids at the 3 for $25 sale, getting three pairs for less than $10 each!

Some of the premium modal blends and performance fabrics cost a few dollars more, around $12-18 per pair. That’s still very affordable compared to high-end brands.

I always check the clearance racks too – today I scored some navy striped boxers for only $6! Keep an eye out for clearance sales to get epic deals. Sign up for email alerts too.

Between the regular sales and extra clearance markdowns, Old Navy is my go-to for getting lots of quality boxers without breaking the bank.

Mixing and Matching Single Pairs

Rather than buying packs, I like to hand-pick single pairs to mix and match. This allows me to choose specific prints and colors to build the perfect underwear collection.

Old Navy makes this easy by offering a ton of individual boxers in fun colors and bold prints. I picked up a few solids like navy, gray, and black as base colors.

Then I added some bright colors like green, orange, and blue for a fun accent. The range of shades allows me to coordinate with my outfit or suit my mood.

To satisfy my playful side, I got a few patterned and graphic boxers too. Old Navy has some really unique prints like tropical leaves, polka dots, plaid, and stylized text. They bring a nice visual pop.

Buying singles allows me to customize my stash of boxers. I can also replace worn pairs as needed rather than buying full multi-packs.

Variety of Prints and Graphics

One thing that sets Old Navy apart is the wide selection of original prints and graphics on their boxers. They have an in-house design team that develops unique all-over patterns and visual details.

Some of my favorites this season are the tropical floral prints with monstera leaves and abstract flowers. The colors are bold and vibrant. I also love the whimsical critter prints with hedgehogs, sloths, and cats in fun poses.

There are lots of cool graphic boxers too, with distressed-style athletic logos, retro video game themes, and abstract geometric shapes. The variety of artwork keeps things interesting compared to solid colors.

I appreciate that many designs are made in collaboration with different artists and influencers. Old Navy also partners with brands like Nintendo for officially licensed prints I can’t find elsewhere.

Performance-Ready for Sports and Active Lifestyles

Since I like to stay active, I appreciate that Old Navy has performance boxer briefs designed for exercise and sports.

The quick-dry mesh fabric and four-way stretch construction allow for full range of motion. These boxers won’t restrict movement during intense workouts.

They also have moisture-wicking properties to keep you cool and dry. The boxer brief cut provides compression and support without compromising on comfort.

I grabbed a few pairs of the breathable performance boxers for hiking, cycling, yoga, and other activities. It’s nice not having to worry about discomfort or chafing when breaking a sweat.

Old Navy tests their activewear to ensure it can handle any workout. I feel confident these boxer briefs will be comfortable and durable whether I’m at the gym, on a run, or chasing after my kids in the backyard.

Caring for and Washing Old Navy Boxers

One of the most important factors for me is finding boxers that will hold up over time. Based on experience, Old Navy’s boxer shorts stand the test of frequent washing.

The majority can be machine washed and dried. I always use cold water and tumble dry low/medium to avoid excessive shrinkage. So far, my Old Navy boxers have maintained their fit and softness.

For the premium modal blends, I take extra care and line dry to prevent pilling. The performance fabrics hold up well to regular laundering but air drying also helps preserve the technical properties.

Ideally, I wash my boxers after 1 or 2 uses. The cotton and mesh materials naturally resist odor so the shorts don’t need to be washed as frequently as undershirts. But regular laundering helps extend the life of the boxers.

With proper care, my Old Navy boxer shorts last for years of wear. The quality is excellent considering the affordable prices.

Prioritizing Comfort and Wearability

As someone who wears boxer shorts daily, comfort is my number one priority. I need underwear that feels great all day, without digging, bunching, or chafing.

Old Navy boxers check every box when it comes to comfort! The soft fabrics conform to your body, moving with you without restriction. Wide waistbands don’t pinch or bind. Leg openings are smooth and stay in place.

I also appreciate the range of sizes and cuts to fit different body types. The fuller cuts provide enough coverage and the performance boxer briefs offer athletic support. There are no uncomfortable seams or scratchy labels.

Beyond soft fabrics, Old Navy incorporates special features for superior comfort. Some boxers have moisture-wicking properties to stay dry. The mesh panels and 4-way stretch offer ventilation and freedom of movement. Wide waistbands stay smooth against the skin.

After a full day of wearing my new Old Navy boxers, I can confirm they live up to their reputation for comfort. I barely notice I’m wearing them!

Online Shopping and Delivery

While I love browsing for boxers in store, Old Navy also makes it easy to shop online. Their website allows you to filter by size, style, color, price and other factors to streamline your search.

I like being able to read customer reviews for feedback on fit and quality for particular boxer models. Detailed product descriptions provide additional sizing guidance and fabric details.

Old Navy offers free shipping for orders over $50. Underwear ships quickly so I get my new boxers within a few days. Returns are free too – just drop at a mail center or store if needed.

I saved my picks to an online Wish List to finalize my order later. The website conveniently stores payment and shipping info to check out faster.

For the ultimate convenience, customers can select repeat delivery to automatically get new underwear delivered every 3, 6 or 12 months. I may set this up to effortlessly restock my favorites!

Return Policy and Guarantee

One of the biggest advantages Old Navy has over other brands is their excellent return policy.

If you’re not completely satisfied with your boxers, returns are free and easy. Items can be returned by mail or at your local store within 45 days in new condition with the original tags.

I really appreciate that I can actually try on the boxers at home to determine fit and comfort. If something doesn’t work for my body, I can easily exchange or get a refund.

For online orders, you can print a free return label to send items back. No return authorization is required. Once received, Old Navy will issue a full refund to the original payment.

It’s this risk-free guarantee that gives me confidence purchasing boxers from Old Navy. I know I can get my money back if anything doesn’t meet my standards.

Sizing for All Ages

Luckily, Old Navy doesn’t only cater to men – they have a great selection of women’s and children’s underwear too!

For women, Old Navy offers bikini, hipster, and boyshort cuts in tons of colors. There are also boxer briefs, boyshorts, and trunks for girls.

It’s convenient that I can pick up underwear for my whole family in one place. The kids’ patterns are really cute – my daughter loves the unicorn print boxers.

Kids sizes range from XS to XL so there are options as your little ones grow. The fabrics and construction hold up well to childhood adventures!

I appreciate that Old Navy underwear comes in family packs with a mix of children’s sizes. This makes it easy to buy for multiple kids of different ages at once.

Eco-Friendly and Sustainable Fabrics

As I become more conscious of sustainability, I try to support brands making eco-friendly apparel. I was happy to find out Old Navy has some great sustainable underwear options.

They partner with materials innovator BCI to offer boxers made from organic cotton grown without toxic pesticides and synthetic fertilizers. Old Navy also uses recycled polyester made from plastic bottles diverted from landfills.

These steps help reduce environmental impact from manufacturing. I don’t have to sacrifice comfort or style to make sustainable choices.

Old Navy is transparent about their sustainability practices. They aim to use 100% sustainably-sourced cotton by 2025. As a major retailer, they have the scale to drive industry improvements.

I’ll definitely be buying more of the eco-friendly boxer shorts and briefs to reduce my fashion footprint. Small steps like this collectively make a difference!

New Styles and Frequent Releases

One benefit of Old Navy’s market dominance is they are constantly launching new styles and updating their inventory.

They release new prints and graphics every season so there is always something fresh to catch your eye. Thematic collections like summer tropical prints or holiday boxers keep things interesting.

Beyond new patterns, Old Navy is often first to market with on-trend cuts like low-rise trunks or retro inspired designs. Their in-house team stays ahead of emerging styles.

I try to stop by every couple months to see what’s new. Occasional redesigns improve fit and add technical features like four-way stretch. Returning shoppers have a reason to keep coming back.

Frequent turnover means there is always a supply of clearance boxers as last season’s inventory gets marked down. More savings for loyal customers like me!

Creating Lounge Sets

One great thing about Old Navy is you can easily build a full head-to-toe lounge outfit. Their underwear pairs perfectly with their expansive selection of comfy clothes.

I like to stock up on soft joggers and cotton tees to create a matching athleisure set. Add some patterned boxer shorts into the mix and I have a cool weekend look.

The boxer briefs with moisture-wicking performance fabrics complement Old Navy’s activewear like joggers, shorts and tanks. I can head straight from the gym to running errands.

With kids at home, I also appreciate being able to buy family jammies. Old Navy has a great selection of plaid flannel pants, graphic tees, and onesies to create coordinated sleep outfits.

Mixing and matching from across categories helps maximize your wardrobe. Boxer shorts from Old Navy seamlessly integrate into relaxed everyday looks.

Reviews From Fellow Customers

Beyond my own experience, I always like to read reviews from other customers before making a purchase. This helps me identify particularly beloved or recommended products.

Looking at Old Navy boxers, the overwhelming majority of reviews are positive. Guys report the underwear is comfortable, breathable, and durable even after repeated washing. Many customers have been buying Old Navy boxers for years.

Some reviewers note the great value, especially when on sale. Others say Old Navy boxers are comparable in quality to premium brands like Calvin Klein for a fraction of the price.

The few negative comments seem to be around sizing and fir rather than issues with quality or comfort. This reinforces my advice to carefully consult the size charts and try on multiple sizes for the best fit.

Overall, the glowing feedback gives me confidence I’m making a great choice shopping Old Navy for boxers. I’m happy to join the legions of loyal customers.

Special Features for Comfort

Beyond fabric and cut, Old Navy incorporates special features to enhance comfort in their boxers.

One that stands out to me is the ComfortFlex waistband. This woven elastic brace has more give to move with you without pinching or binding. It has a smooth, chafe-free edge.

Many styles also have no-gap fly construction for extra support. This prevents the placket from separating and improves containment.

For all-day wear, I appreciate the tagless label that eliminates neck irritation and scratching. Flatlock seams minimize friction and contours flexibly.

It’s small details like these that separate Old Navy’s boxers from cheaper generics. The attention to comfort makes their boxers some of my absolute favorites to wear. It’s worth investing a few extra dollars for these premium features.

Maximizing Savings with Loyalty Programs

As if the regular sales weren’t good enough, Old Navy sweetens the deal by offering special loyalty programs.

The free Old Navy Rewards program provides members early access to sales and exclusive offers. You earn points for purchases that translate into reward dollars off future shopping trips.

Make sure to sign up for emails – members get alerts about extra discounts, personalized promotions, and free shipping.

Around the holidays, Old Navy sends Reward members coupons for percentage discounts or money off an order. They often run Buy One Get One 50% Off offers on underwear when you use your rewards card.

Between the regular promos and loyalty rewards, I almost always save at least 30% on my boxer purchases at Old Navy. Joining the free program is a no-brainer for frequent shoppers.

Staying on Top of New Releases

With new inventory dropping all the time, it’s hard to keep up with all the latest styles. Luckily, Old Navy makes it easy to stay in the know about new arrivals.

The easiest way is to sign up for email updates through their website or mobile app. I get notifications about new product launches, upcoming sales, and seasonal collections delivered right to my inbox.

Make sure to provide your clothing preferences so the emails can be tailored to styles you’ll actually want to shop. I designated boxers and loungewear as my categories.

Old Navy is also very active on social media, especially Instagram. Following their accounts is a great way to see new prints and designs as soon as they are released. User-generated hashtags like #oldnavystyle also give previews.

Between emails and social media, I’m always inspired to head in store and see the new boxer shorts for each season. It satisfies my inner bargain shopper to score the latest styles at discounted prices.

The Search for the Perfect Boxers Continues…

After thoroughly combing through Old Navy’s expansive underwear selection, I successfully restocked my supply of boxer shorts for the foreseeable future.

But the quest for the perfect pair never really ends. I’m excited to see what new prints, colors, and styles Old Navy comes up with next season. The range of options keeps shopping for boxer shorts fun and interesting each time.

For affordable, quality underwear that looks good and feels great, Old Navy can’t be beat. I leave fully satisfied with my purchases knowing I got the best possible value. Their boxers have earned a permanent place in both my dresser and my shopping plans.

Now that I’ve shared my experiences and tips, I hope more guys will consider Old Navy for all their underwear needs. Let me know if you have a favorite style or print I should check out on my next visit! I’m always open to recommendations from fellow Old Navy shoppers.

We will be happy to hear your thoughts

Leave a reply